Rivalry head-to-head

Northern Illinois takes the argument.

Northern Illinois wins 1 of the 5 arguments, 4 too close to call.

Series tied 24-24-1· Ball State has won 3 of the last 5.

A long-running Midwest series.

Northern IllinoisNo. 126 · MWC1arguments won

4 too close to call

Ball StateNo. 127 · MAC0arguments won

The series49 meetings since 1968 · through 2025

Dead even at 24-24-1

Ball State has won 3 of the last 5.

Dead even at 24-24-1, back to 1968. Nobody has ever settled this one.

The last 5 meetings

2025Northern Illinois21-7at Northern Illinois
2024Ball State25-23at Ball State
2023Ball State20-17at Northern Illinois
2022Ball State44-38at Ball State
2021Northern Illinois30-29at Northern Illinois

All-time series from the public game record (CollegeFootballData).

Argument by argument

Tap any argument to open Verdict's full run — the same numbers the Settle page serves, unchanged.

Every argument is Verdict's own published run, unchanged. An argument only declares a winner when its own numbers do — otherwise it is recorded as too close to call and counts for neither side.

Continue the investigation

Another rivalry Northern Illinois's case Ball State's case All eighteen arguments