All rivalries
Rivalry head-to-head
Toledo takes the argument.
Toledo wins 4 of the 5 arguments, Northern Illinois 1.
Toledo leads 36-17· Toledo has won the last 4.
A repeat conference-championship matchup.
The series53 meetings since 1967 · through 2025
Toledo leads 36-17
Toledo has won the last 4.
Toledo leads the all-time series 36-17, back to 1967.
The last 5 meetings
- 2025Toledo42-3at Toledo
- 2024Toledo13-6at Northern Illinois
- 2023Toledo35-33at Toledo
- 2022Toledo52-32at Northern Illinois
- 2021Northern Illinois22-20at Toledo
All-time series from the public game record (CollegeFootballData).
Argument by argument
Tap any argument to open Verdict's full run — the same numbers the Settle page serves, unchanged.
Every argument is Verdict's own published run, unchanged. An argument only declares a winner when its own numbers do — otherwise it is recorded as too close to call and counts for neither side.
Continue the investigation
